In Swamped, MSAC Collective and AM Stuart turn extraterrestrial mythologies into a provocative meditation on authorship, authenticity and Othered identity within the contemporary gallery.
Truth, fiction and extraterrestrial identity inside Swamped at Goolugatup Heathcote
7 October 2026
- Reading time • 9 minutesVisual Art
More like this
- Erin Coates gives extinction a body, and asks us to look closer
- The Dynamic Field of Relation: Caroline Christie-Coxon’s Circularity
- Home, waste and identity take centre stage at MJAC
Cover image: Swamped: Stella Barrett and anonymous (MSAC Collective), PRO-FILES: ET GO HOME (Tinfoil Hat), Organised by AM Stuart, 2020, laser print on paper, plastic sleeves, pins, variable dimensions, Detail. Photography by Aaron Claringbold
Swamped – MSAC Collective
Goolugatup Heathcote, until 25 October 2026
Mystery shrouds Swamped, one of the current exhibitions showing at Goolugatup Heathcote. Swamped presents works by three artists belonging to MSAC Collective — a group united by their identification as diasporic extraterrestrials (ET) embodied in human form. The exhibition features paintings, drawings and prints by MSAC members L. Tan and Stella Barrett, along with a third anonymous collaborator, that together consider various contested representations of ET.
Swamped is organised by Boorloo-born, Naarm-based artist and MSAC emissary AM Stuart. Stuart’s connections with the collective stem from her relationship with previous collaborator Miki Okatsuka, a Japanese art historian. In a 2024 exhibition project, Stuart loaned works from the Okatsuka Collection, including two by Edvard Munch, two by Kazimir Malevich and one by Grace Cossington-Smith. Equally puzzling and intriguing, Stuart presented these works at TCB, an artist-run space in Melbourne, with entirely incongruous facilities for displaying institutional loans of priceless works of art.

Photo: Aaron Claringbold.
The context of Stuart’s elusive previous projects pulls Swamped into focus – an exhibition that raises more questions than it answers. In characteristic Stuart fashion, we are invited into an enigmatic corner of the art world.
Tucked down the hall in Goolugatup Heathcote’s smaller galleries, Swamped occupies two rooms, the first being a darkened space with misaligned contour spotlighting, attempting to illuminate the wall-based works. The hang feels sombre and vaguely institutional, yet off-kilter, creating an atmosphere somewhere between an archive, an investigation room and an occult meeting place. In the shadows, perched on a wooden mantelpiece, lurks a tiny grey alien figurine.


Swamped: L. Tan, m(Other)ships: UFO witness drawing 1990 (I) & (II), Organised by AM Stuart, 2007, oil on linen, 650 x 650 mm.Photography by Aaron Claringbold.
We are first met with L. Tan’s m(Other)ships oil painting series, which repeats yellow, black and orange geometric forms, evoking naively drawn spacecraft. Stella Barrett’s Close Encounter of the Fifth Kind (CE5) Meditation I and II (exogenic visions) depict what appear to be sections of a Rorschach test layered upon the textures of meteorite or planetary surfaces. In the exhibition’s starkly lit second room, a series of pinned A4 black-and-white laser prints fills the walls, forming large-scale collages comprising sections of redacted text, distorted black-and-white archival images and sections of a filing system belonging to an unidentified department. Overlapping red and yellow circles, evoking an unruly Venn diagram, suggest an ambiguous act of mapping or processing.


Stella Barrett and Anonymous (MSAC Collective), PRO-FILES: ET GO HOME (Tinfoil Hat), Organised by AM Stuart, 2020, artist book (left) and laser print on paper (right), 297 x 420 mm. Photography by Aaron Claringbold.
As revealed in an interview between Stuart and Goolugatup’s curator, Paul Boyé, published to accompany the exhibition, these works take the popular visual language of ET aliens to unpack an “authentic” expression of Othered identity. Contextualising the artistic intent behind Barrett and Tan’s works, the interview reveals that Barrett’s paintings depict portraits of her kin, rendered through a meditation practice, while Tan’s illustrate the spacecraft that would regularly visit the artist’s mother. Drawing a parallel between the ET alien and the racialised Other, the works in this exhibition grapple with the politics of representation, highlighting not only “performed”, and therefore legible, identity but also genuine cultural expression.
The significance of Swamped is therefore twofold. First, Swamped operates within a framework of layered conspiracies. While the works in the exhibition employ the language of extraterrestrial encounters and pseudoscience, they also turn these ideas back onto the institution exhibiting them and the art world at large — an environment often structured through, and maintained by, veneers of institutional authority. Goolugatup Heathcote is known for presenting many expanded forms of contemporary art. However, in this context, the exhibition unsettles the authority of the gallery itself, exposing the conventions through which certain forms of knowledge and cultural expression are granted legitimacy while others are dismissed.
Swamped extends this logic to the artists themselves. When we begin questioning the legitimacy of the people behind these works, and the sincerity of their intentions, the audience enters a debate lying at the heart of contemporary art: who gets to be an artist, and what allows us to recognise their work as legitimate?

Most compellingly, Swamped draws attention to the treatment of perceived and actual expressions of ethnocultural heritage within the gallery space. The identity of the ET, a figure familiar to many of us through popular culture, is used to highlight the dual stigmatisation and sensationalism that attaches to the figure of the Other.
Behind its shroud of mystery, the exhibition turns its attention to the ways in which the Other is constructed, interpreted and legitimised within the gallery. The exhibition consequently enters into dialogue with one of the central debates of contemporary culture: the battle between truth and fiction.
Through Swamped, a world of absurdity opens up, populated by extraterrestrial figures and conspiratorial possibilities. Yet the absurdity of this exhibition is not entirely separate from the realities of our own world.
Swamped runs at Goolugatup Heathcote till 25th October 2026.
Like what you're reading? Support Seesaw.




