Collaboration brings out the best

17 May 2021

Stuffy traditions are pushed aside in a performance of Mendelssohn’s Elijah which Sandra Bowdler says is brought to life with imagination and solid musical values.

Elijah, West Australian Opera and UWA Conservatorium of Music ·
Winthrop Hall, 16 May 2021 ·

These days Mendelssohn’s Elijah can seem quite archaic; in fact it was old fashioned when it premiered in 1846. The composer was aiming for the gravity and sacred aura of Handel’s English oratorios and banished from it any element of post-1800 composition. However the briefest comparison with Handel’s Old Testament oratorios shows that Mendelssohn really had no idea how to transmute those messy stories into dramatic gold.

After the thunderous success of its first performance at Birmingham, enthusiasm for Elijah waned over the decades, with an anti-Semitic attack from Wagner – Mendelssohn’s family was Jewish in origin but had converted to Lutheranism – and the ultimate put-down from George Bernard Shaw who attacked the author’s “kid glove gentility, his conventional sentimentality, and his despicable oratorio mongering.” 

On the other hand, there is great drama in some of the choral chunks in Elijah, and lyrical passages that can be most enjoyable. This performance – a collaboration between the West Australian Opera company and the Conservatorium of Music at the University of Western Australia – managed to shake off some of the work’s cobwebs, with semi-staging, subtle lighting and strong musical values down to director Margrete Helgeby Chaney, lighting designer Mark Howett, conductor Christopher van Tuinen and choral director Andrew Foote. It was somewhat truncated, with some choruses and the whole widow’s son episode omitted; I doubt anyone much noticed.

A woman in a white jacket sings with arms outstretched, bathed in hazy orange light. She shares the stage with people in casual clothes, seated on the floor.
Soprano Lisa Harper-Brown is bathed with orange light as she shares the stage with the chorus in ‘Elijah’. Photo: James Rogers

UWA’s Winthrop Hall is a structure designed for graduations with no proscenium arch or other trappings of an operatic venue, but an alternative performing space was created by locating the orchestra on the stage and organising the audience in bleachers around a central platform over and around which the principals and choral members flowed, with use also made of the colonnaded upper gallery.  As well as the well-deployed lighting, a hazy orange ambience presumably produced by some modern dry ice equivalent filled the hall, perhaps representing the drought of part one, certainly a dramatic detail that modern Australians can relate to. Most of the barefoot performers wore dark coloured casual clothes, including t-shirts, jeans and skirts.  Elijah wore a white uncollared shirt over jeans, with Obadiah in a jacket, perhaps indicating a more bureaucratic role than the demented but holy prophet.

Most of the rank and file were music students, comprising the UWA Symphony Orchestra and the UWA Symphonic Chorus, augmented by members of the WA Opera chorus. On Sunday night van Tuinen managed to instil discipline and purpose in the orchestra and the singers, no mean feat as they surged around the performance space and up and down from the galleries. Only in the very loudest choruses, such as the huge ponderous finale, did the massed voices lose clarity.

Perth rising star Lachlann Lawton stepped into the title role of Elijah at the last minute. Photo: James Rogers

It was unfortunate that the originally intended Elijah, James Clayton, was indisposed at the last minute, but lucky for his substitute, rising Perth opera star Lachlann Lawton.  Understandably, his acting was less developed than that of the other soloists and he was furthered hampered by having to sing from a book. While he never quite embodied the wild-eyed hectoring prophet, he carried the day with well-articulated singing. His low notes were not always fully audible, and at times he seemed most at home at the top of his range, so it will be interesting to see how he develops.

Lisa Harper-Brown has spent some years singing in Germany until returning to Perth a few years ago, and, particularly in ‘Hear ye, Israel’ her voice was powerful and her stage presence authoritative. Emerging singer mezzo-soprano Chelsea Kluga impressed with ‘Woe unto them’.  Tenor Paul O’Neill has a fine clarion tenor and an easy stage confidence which served him well as Obadiah. Several members of the chorus appeared to advantage in minor parts, notably Wilson Kang as Ahab and soprano Abbie Radford whose beautifully pure high notes provided some memorable moments. Overall, the student performers were an asset in this lively production which was greeted with warm applause on this final night.

West Australian Opera’s next performance is ‘Cav & Pag’ running 17-24 July.

The UWA Conservatorium’s next performance is ‘Chamber Music Salon’ by the Irwin Street Collective on 20 May.

Pictured top: Christopher van Tuinen is bathed in orange light as he conducts ‘Elijah’, a collaboration between the UWA Conservatorium and West Australian Opera. Photo: James Rogers

Like what you're reading? Support Seesaw.

Author —
Sandra Bowdler

Sandra Bowdler is an archaeologist who has been writing about music for some twenty years, most recently for Opera magazine (UK), Bachtrack and Handel News. She is also the author of “Handel’s Operas in Australia, a performance history” Händel Jarhbuch (2017). Her favourite piece of playground equipment would be the picnic bench with smoked salmon sandwiches and champagne.

Past Articles

  • Handel’s masterwork – 280 years and not out

    Handel’s Messiah was first performed in Easter Week, 1742 and Sandra Bowdler has found a revival of that event that was near perfection.

  • Musical fireworks

    Remarkable performances by soprano Sara Macliver and conductor Dane Lam light up this concert by the WA Symphony Orchestra, reports Sandra Bowdler.

Read Next

  • Outcome Unknown. Two people sit at tables in a darkened space. One is plucking at stringed instruments lying flat on the desk and the other in the foreground is adjusting electronic keyboards Electronica surges at Outcome Unknown

    Electronica surges at Outcome Unknown

    1 July 2022

    The Outcome Unknown Festival brings together some of Perth’s leading players in experimental music, and highlights the strength in the electronica field, writes Jonathan W. Marshall.

    Reading time • 7 minutesMusic
  • Reading time • 6 minutesVisual Art
  • Reading time • 5 minutesTheatre

Cleaver Street Studio

Cleaver Street Studio

Cleaver Street Studio