Musical fireworks

8 November 2021

Remarkable performances by soprano Sara Macliver and conductor Dane Lam light up this concert by the WA Symphony Orchestra, reports Sandra Bowdler.

“Landscape and Wonder”, WA Symphony Orchestra ·
Perth Concert Hall, 5 November 2021 ·

Remember, remember, the fifth of November
Gunpowder treason and plot …

It may have been serendipitous that, on the fifth of November (Guy Fawkes Night) fireworks of different kinds livened up the West Australian Symphony Orchestra’s “Landscape and Wonder” concert. 

The opener was Prokofiev’s ever-popular Symphony No. 1, called by the composer the “Classical”.  Premiered in 1917, four years after that touchstone of modernism Stravinsky’s Le sacre du printemps, Prokofiev harks back to the classical period to provide a standard framework for his symphony, Allegro-Larghetto-Gavotte-Finale, filling it with modernist touches, such as dissonances and unexpected key changes.

This lively and accessible work is well served by the exuberant conducting of Dane Lam, conductor of the Xi’an Symphony Orchestra and Associate Music Director and Resident Conductor of Opera Queensland. His super brisk opening gave notice that we were in for a delightful ride, thereafter slowing down for a more lyrical reading. After maintaining a light touch in the famous Larghetto (which pops up again in Prokofiev’s ballet Romeo and Juliet), we were off to a racing finish with a sparkling Molto vivace (very much lively) Finale.

Sibelius’s Symphony No 5 was described in the program as one of his most “shining, life-affirming creations”, which it is, compared to its predecessor, the Symphony No 4. Compared to the Prokofiev however it is a lot less successful in pouring new wine into old bottles, in this case an even more formal structure of Tempo molto moderato – Andante mosso – Allegro molto. Each of these movements contains an assortment of short sub-movements, many of them providing opportunities for, variously, strings, woodwinds, brass, and percussion. The second movement can become quite murky, as if the whole thing is about to descend into some messy chaos, but tonight it is saved by the clearly articulated playing of the orchestra. The ending is full of fiery bombast, extremely well-played by orchestra and conductor.

A lady in a black dress sings in front of an orchestera
Sara Macliver sings Golijov’s ‘Three Songs’ as though they had been written for her. Photo supplied

In between these examples of early modernism is interpolated Golijov’s Three Songs for Soprano and Orchestra, composed less than twenty years ago, which could, given the juxtaposition of some very different formal and cultural elements, be described as post-modern. Originally written for American soprano Dawn Upshaw, we were graced with the similarly pure and radiant voice of Sara Macliver. 

Looking at the texts on the printed page hardly prepared one for the complexity of the compositions, particularly the first song “Night of the flying horses”, which segues into two whole orchestral movements following the sung words. The Yiddish lyrics have a lullaby feel reminiscent of Gershwin’s “Summertime”. The first two verses are sung a capella, then the voice is joined by strings played pizzicato, with the singing followed by orchestration featuring flutes and clarinets reminiscent of klezmer music, culminating in a wild gypsy dance. 

“Lúa Descolorido” owes more to the world of Hispanic music, the lyrics being in Gallego, from Galicia in Spain, the singer immersed in sadness and the music being quietly rhythmic.  “How slow the wind”, a setting of two short poems by Emily Dickinson, is also a song of gentle rhythmic sadness with much percussion that rumbles along beneath the floating voice of the soprano.

While this might seem far from Macliver’s usual fare, like much contemporary music it calls for what might be thought of as Baroque technique, rather than (for instance) the over the top vocalism of romantic opera. The judicious use of vibrato and disciplined control of long-breathed phrases are all in abundant evidence. These songs also display the sheer gorgeousness of Macliver’s upper range, and the richness of the middle-low part of her voice.  Yes, they were written for someone else, but they could just as easily have been written for Sara Macliver.

The next performance by the WA Symphony Orchestra is “Last Night at the Proms” on 12-13 November 2021.

Pictured top: Dane Lam conducts the WA Symphony Orchestra. Photo supplied

Like what you're reading? Support Seesaw.

Author —
Sandra Bowdler

Sandra Bowdler is an archaeologist who has been writing about music for some twenty years, most recently for Opera magazine (UK), Bachtrack and Handel News. She is also the author of “Handel’s Operas in Australia, a performance history” Händel Jarhbuch (2017). Her favourite piece of playground equipment would be the picnic bench with smoked salmon sandwiches and champagne.

Past Articles

  • Massive Mozart

    Mozart’s Mass in C minor is one of his more sublime masterpieces, but its impact was somewhat mitigated by unbalanced forces, says Sandra Bowdler

  • A musical reunion in less than ideal conditions

    HIP Company marks its first anniversary with an ambitious program that Sandra Bowdler says is hampered somewhat by technology and the choice of venue.

Read Next

  • Two people stand against a black backdrop holding large material puppet figures of a child and a woman holding a book Snot saves the day

    Snot saves the day

    25 January 2022

    A puppet show about a child with a big, snotty nose as ridiculous as it sounds, says Kobi Morrison, and the beautiful madness has kids and adults hooked.

    Reading time • 3 minutesTheatre
  • Three performers are on a stage against a backdrop of a giant green star. Two of the performer stand with their arms and legs spread wide while they hold the legs of the third, who is doing a handstand between them Rising stars have it all

    Rising stars have it all

    25 January 2022

    Stardom is an elusive dream, as the cast of ALLSTARS make clear, but David Zampatti sees plenty of evidence to suggest this exciting trio have what it takes.

    Reading time • 5 minutesFringe World Festival
  • Photo: Georgi Ivers A woman stands centre stage, in her underwear, with a cushion strapped to her stomach to mimic pregnancy. She leans back awkwardly from the hips, one arm extended. She is surrounded by elaborately framed photos of herself pulling funny faces. Childbirth stripped bare

    Childbirth stripped bare

    25 January 2022

    A visceral and highly physical story of one woman’s experience of childbirth – in all its guts and glory – The Dirty Mother is a performance that demands to be heard says Claire Trolio.

    Reading time • 5 minutesFringe World Festival

Cleaver Street Studio

Cleaver Street Studio

Cleaver Street Studio